Dutch Valley Restaurant Menu

Welcome to Dutch Valley Restaurant, a beloved family dining spot located in Sugarcreek, Ohio. Nestled at 1343 Old Rte 39 NE, this lively establishment offers a delightful culinary experience that keeps patrons returning time and again.

The menu at Dutch Valley is a treasure trove of flavors, featuring a diverse buffet that is sure to please every palate. Diners rave about the extensive salad bar, packed with fresh options, and the homemade baked goods that are simply irresistible.

  • Hearty Offerings: Enjoy a succulent roast beef dinner or juicy broasted chicken, both praised for their tenderness and flavor.
  • Carefully Crafted Salads: Try the strawberry salad with grilled chicken, a refreshing option adored by many.
  • Remarkable Service: Friendly staff, like Tina and Erica, enhance the dining experience with their attentive and welcoming demeanor.

Join us at Dutch Valley Restaurant, where every meal is served with warmth and hospitality!

Cookie A La Mode

Chocolate chip cookie and ice cream topped with hot fudge and whipped topping

US$5.28

Ho Ho Cake-Slice

US$5.16

Strawberry Shortcake

US$5.74

Date Nut Pudding

Traditional spice cake made with dates and walnuts. Served warm with caramel sauce

US$5.74

Apple Dumpling

US$6.08

Add Fruit Topping

US$2.06

Angel Food Cake

US$4.59

16 Pieces Chicken

4 Breasts, 4 Thighs, 4 Legs, & 4 Wings

US$41.39

24 Pieces Chicken

6 Breasts, 6 Thighs, 6 Legs, & 6 Wings

US$58.64

20 Pieces Chicken

5 Breasts, 5 Thighs, 5 Legs, & 5 Wings

US$50.59

12 Pieces Chicken

3 Breasts, 3 Thighs, 3 Legs, & 3 Wings

US$32.19

8 Pieces Chicken

2 Breasts, 2 Thighs, 2 Legs, & 2 Wings

US$21.84

Family-Sized Potato Salad

US$6.49

Family-Sized Coleslaw

US$6.49

Family-Sized Macaroni Salad

US$6.49

Trail Bologna Sandwich

Troyer’s Trail Bologna served hot or cold with Guggisberg Baby Swiss

US$13.37

Roast Beef Sandwich

Slow-roasted in its own juices

US$14.52

Roast Turkey Sandwich

Slow-roasted in its own juices

US$14.52

Cod Sandwich

Hand-breaded and deep-fried cod filet

US$15.10

Dutchman Burger

8oz Chopped sirloin topped with Swiss cheese

US$15.10

Roast Pork Sandwich

Slow-roasted in its own juices

US$14.52

Grilled Cheese

Famous & local Guggisberg Baby Swiss with thick slices of our homemade bread

US$10.27

Grilled Chicken B.L.T.

Boneless grilled chicken breast with bacon, lettuce and tomato

US$16.25

Grilled Ham & Cheese

Old fashioned grilled ham with your choice of cheese

US$13.37

BBQ Pork Sandwich

Juicy pulled pork smothered in our homemade BBQ sauce

US$14.52

Cheeseburger

Beef patty topped with American cheese

US$14.29

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

Boneless grilled chicken breast

US$14.52

B.L.T

Bacon, crisp lettuce and tomato served on white or wheat toast

US$13.72

Bottled Water

US$2.63

Water

US$0.00

5 Pieces Chicken Wings

US$9.19

6 Chicken Tenders

US$13.79

20 Pieces Chicken Wings

US$28.74

10 Pieces Chicken Wings

US$16.09

12 Chicken Tenders

US$25.29

Regular Coffee

US$3.44

Hot Tea

US$3.44

Sweet Iced Tea

US$3.78

Half Tea / Half Lemonade

US$3.78

Unsweet Iced Tea

US$3.78

Decaf Coffee

US$3.44

Roast Turkey Dinner

Old-fashioned slow-roasted turkey

US$19.54

Roast Pork Dinner

Slow-roasted to perfection in its own juices

US$18.39

Ham Dinner

Grilled or baked in pineapple glaze

US$18.39

Baked Ham By Pound

Lb

US$17.24

Roast Turkey-Mix By Pound

Lb

US$19.54

Roast Pork By Pound

Lb

US$17.24

Roast Turkey - White Meat By Pound

Lb

US$20.69

Roast Beef By Pound

Lb

US$21.84

Vegetable Beef Soup

Hearty beef broth with roast beef and a medley of vegetables

US$4.29

Chicken Noodle Soup

Heartwarming chicken broth with Essenhaus noodles and vegetables

US$4.29

Broccoli Cheese Soup

A creamy base with cheese and broccoli

US$4.29

German Chocolate Pie-Slice

US$5.74

Rhubarb Custard Pie-Slice

US$6.31

Cherry Pie-Slice

US$5.74

Custard Pie-Slice

US$5.74

Peach Pie-Slice

US$5.74

Oatmeal Pie-Slice

A sweet and gooey filling with oats and cinnamon sugar baked into our delicious pie crust.

US$5.74

Lemon Meringue Pie-Slice

US$5.74

Dutch Apple Pie-Slice

US$5.74

Blueberry Pie-Slice

US$5.74

Pecan Pie-Slice

US$6.31

Apple Pie-Slice

US$5.74

Dutch Apple W/Caramel Slice

US$5.74

NSA Cherry Pie-Slice

US$6.31

Blackberry Pie-Slice

US$5.74

NSA Apple Pie-Slice

US$6.31

White Milk

US$4.59

Chocolate Milk

US$4.59

Diet Mountain Dew

US$3.78

Mountain Dew

US$3.78

Dr. Pepper

US$3.78

Diet Pepsi

US$3.78

Starry

US$3.78

Pepsi

US$3.78

Raspberry Iced Tea

US$3.78

Pepsi Zero

US$3.78

Soda Water

US$2.29

Root Beer

US$3.78

Lemonade

US$3.78

Family-Sized Green Beans

US$6.49

Family-Sized Corn

Creamed corn

US$6.49

Family-Sized Dressing

Bread dressing with choice of beef or chicken gravy

US$6.49

Family-Sized Noodles

Essenhaus noodles cooked in chicken broth

US$6.49

Family-Sized Gravy

Beef or chicken gravy

US$0.00

Family-Sized Mac & Cheese

US$6.49

Family-Sized Mashed Potatoes

Homemade mashed potatoes with choice of beef or chicken gravy

US$6.49

Cottage Cheese-Side

US$4.59

Noodles-Side

Cooked in chicken broth

US$4.59

Waffle Fries-Side

US$4.59

Creamed Corn-Side

US$4.59

Baked Sweet Potato-Side

US$5.16

Green Beans-Side

US$4.59

Potato Wedges-Side

US$5.16

Baked Potato-Side

US$4.59

Broccoli-Side

US$4.59

Onion Rings-Side

US$5.16

French Fries-Side

US$4.59

Dressing-Side

Served with beef or chicken gravy

US$4.59

Applesauce-Side

US$4.59

Fresh Fruit-Side

US$5.16

Mashed Potatoes-Side

Served with beef or chicken gravy

US$4.59

Coleslaw-Side

US$4.59

Mac & Cheese-Side

US$4.59

Sweet Potato Fries-Side

US$5.16

Red Beets-Side

US$4.59

Tossed Salad-Side

Mixed greens topped with carrots, tomatoes, cucumbers, cheese, and homemade croutons

US$5.16

Potato Salad-Side

US$4.59

Chicken Tenders Dinner

4 Crispy fried chicken tenders

US$17.24

Grilled Chicken Breast Dinner

Boneless chicken breast

US$17.24

Broasted Chicken Dinner

Broasted chicken is marinated, breaded and broasted under pressure – crispy outside, juicy inside

US$15.49

Smothered Chicken Breast Dinner

Boneless chicken breast smothered with Swiss cheese, mushrooms and bacon

US$20.11

Chicken Wings Dinner

6 Broasted chicken wings

US$17.81

Baked Chicken Dinner

Baked Chicken is seasoned, breaded, pan-fried and then baked until tender

US$15.49

Family-Sized Broccoli Cheese Soup

A creamy base with cheese and broccoli

US$6.49

Family-Sized Vegetable Beef Soup

Hearty beef broth with roast beef and a medley of vegetables

US$6.49

Family-Sized Chicken Noodle Soup

Heartwarming chicken broth with Essenhaus noodles and vegetables

US$6.49

Chef Salad

Crisp lettuce, hardboiled egg, cheese, tomato, onion, croutons, and your choice of grilled chicken breast, ham, turkey, chicken tenders or roast beef

US$16.66

Tossed Salad-Side

Mixed greens topped with carrots, tomatoes, cucumbers, cheese, and homemade croutons

US$5.16

Strawberry Poppyseed Salad

Spinach & romaine topped with candied pecans, strawberries, feta cheese and charbroiled chicken breast. Served with poppy seed dressing

US$17.24

Chopped Sirloin Dinner

8oz Seasoned and charbroiled chopped sirloin

US$18.96

Loaded Chopped Sirloin Dinner

8oz Seasoned chopped sirloin charbroiled and loaded with Swiss cheese, mushrooms, and onions

US$21.26

Liver & Onions Dinner

Grilled beef liver topped with grilled onions

US$14.79

Swiss Steak Dinner

Cubed round steak baked in beef gravy with mushrooms

US$19.54

Roast Beef Dinner

Old-fashioned slow-roasted in its own juices

US$20.69

Cod Dinner

Mild cod filet, hand-breaded and deep-fried

US$20.69

Seafood Platter

US$22.41

Shrimp Dinner

US$20.69

Salmon Dinner

8oz filet, grilled tender, lightly seasoned or blackened

US$22.41

Pork Manhattan

Hot roast pork sandwich served with mashed potatoes and covered with gravy

US$12.99

Chicken Stir Fry

US$20.11

Noodles Over Mashed Potatoes

Noodles ladled over made-from-scratch mashed potatoes

US$10.79

Roast Beef Manhattan

Hot roast beef sandwich served with mashed potatoes and covered with gravy

US$12.99

Turkey Manhattan

Hot roast turkey sandwich served with mashed potatoes and covered with gravy

US$0.00

Peanut Butter Cream Pie-Slice

US$5.74

Chocolate Cream Pie-Slice

US$5.74

Red Raspberry Cream Pie-Slice

US$5.74

Coconut Cream Pie-Slice

US$5.74

Banana Cream Pie-Slice

US$5.74

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream Pie-Slice

US$5.74

Butterscotch Cream Pie-Slice

US$5.74

French Dip Sub

Slow roasted beef, mushrooms, and onions served with provolone cheese on ciabatta bread with an au jus dipping sauce. Served with your choice of side dish.

US$15.67

Turkey Bacon Burger

Grilled turkey burger topped with Monterey Jack cheese, bacon, sliced avocado, lettuce, tomato and a pepper aioli. Served with your choice of side dish.

US$15.10

Chicken Caesar Wrap

Grilled chicken, homemade Caesar dressing, diced onions, and lettuce rolled up in a tomato basil tortilla and served cold with your choice of side.

US$16.25

Oatmeal Pie (A-La-Mode)-Slice

A sweet and gooey filling with oats and cinnamon sugar baked into our delicious pie crust and served with vanilla ice cream.

US$6.89

Oatmeal Pie-Slice

A sweet and gooey filling with oats and cinnamon sugar baked into our delicious pie crust.

US$5.74

Family Meal For 8

Your choice of one meat, four quart sides, & dinner rolls.

US$101.19

Family Meal For 12

Your choice of one meat, six quart sides, & dinner rolls.

US$144.89

Family Meal For 4

Your choice of one meat, two quart sides, & dinner rolls.

US$52.89

Family Meal For 2

Your choice of one meat, two pint sides, & dinner rolls.

US$27.59

Grapefruit Juice

US$4.59

Orange Juice

US$4.59

Tomato Juice

US$4.59

Cranberry Juice

US$4.59

Grape Juice

US$4.59

Apple Juice

US$4.59

REGISTER

By clicking on “Register Now” button you are accepting the Terms & Conditions